Saturday, May 31, 2014

Steve Jobs

Click on the link below to watch one of the most inspirational videos that I have seen - Steve Jobs speech at Stanford.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gO6cFMRqXqU

Monday, May 26, 2014

Mid-Line Study DE Program Odisha

We just completed the mid-line study report and it took almost close to two and a half months to shift through the massive amount of data generated as part of the study. The study was administered in February 2014. The results are interesting and extremely motivating for me and my team members. Although I had expected an increase of about 10% in student learning outcomes in mathematics, science and geography the results show an increase in the range 25%-30% in the first year itself. The results have been shared with the School and Mass Education Department, Govt. of Odisha. They are interested in integrating the learnings as part of their mathematics and science module development. The study shows a very strong correlation between the DE methodology (Edukit usage, e-Samdhan, collaborative projects, Flipped Classroom methodology, regular coaching and mentoring of teachers by DE resource persons through regular school visits) and the top three performance areas in science, mathematics and geography in case of treatment I schools which clearly brings to light the impact of the DE Program.
As far as grade VI is concerned there has been a 29% increase in average scores (maths, science and geography combined). Similarly in case of grade VII there has been a 23% increase in average scores (maths, science and geography combined). Click on the link below to access the complete report.

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Learning Achievement Levels in Govt. Schools

I am returning back to writing on my blog after a long time and that too with something as serious and complex as "learning achievement levels of kids in government schools." The topic has become a toast for the nation's intelligentsia and strangely eludes an easy solution. As part of my program intervention in government schools in Odisha we did a learning achievement baseline study and the results are interesting. I thought it will be interesting to share the challenges and the key insights thrown up by this study. This study was conducted with more than 5000 students in  87 government upper primary schools spread across six districts of Odisha.
Challenges and Key Insights 
A bottom heavy structure with a large number of students in the lower performing brackets is the main challenge. Almost all of them are back benchers, having very low self-esteem and in need of remediation. Classroom observations show that teachers also are reinforcing the status quo by focussing on the front benchers only. Just training and sensitizing them will not work. Teachers need to be coached and mentored at the school level and constantly sensitized to the fact that they should not be neglecting the back benchers. Equity is the need of the hour and it should be ensured that not only the quality of instruction improves but it also reaches each and every single child.
While the best performing school systems in the world manage to stay at the top by following a beginning of the pipe approach by carefully selecting, meticulously training and grooming the candidates for the job of a teacher, we on the contrary follow an end of the pipe approach by trying to remedy a situation whereby a large chunk of people who do not have any aptitude for teaching, end up as contractual teachers. Entering the teaching profession is an option of the last resort. This has sadly made teaching a low status profession in India, where teaching figures somewhere down the list, as a career option for the young generation. This has created a vicious cycle in that the low status of the profession sends a market signal which attracts poor quality candidates or candidates who take to teaching as a profession of the last resort. Add to this the poor quality of teaching in the teacher training institutes where the trainees do not get much of a practical exposure to teaching at the school level. In addition to that there are a large number of untrained teachers also at the school level.
 

Saturday, May 4, 2013

Is making mistakes an essential part of learning


The answer is yes. A study led by Jason Moser at Michigan State University, expands on this essential part of learning “making mistakes” and how it helps one in learning faster. The question at the heart of the paper is simple: Why are some people so much more effective at learning from their mistakes than others? After all everybody screws up. But what follows is important. Do we ignore the mistake, brushing it aside for the sake of our self-confidence? Or do we investigate the error seeking to learn from the snafu?
The Moser experiment is premised on the fact that there are two distinct reactions to mistakes, both of which can be reliably detected using electroencephalography (EEG). The first reaction is known as error related negativity (ERN). It appears about 50 milliseconds after a screw-up and is believed to originate in the anterior cingulate cortex, a chunk of tissue that helps monitor behaviour, anticipate rewards and regulate attention. This neural reaction is mostly involuntary, the inevitable response to any screw-up. The second signal, which is known as error positivity (Pe), arrives anywhere between 100-500 milliseconds after the mistake and is associated with awareness. It occurs when we pay attention to the error, dwelling on the disappointing result. In recent years, numerous studies have shown that subjects learn more effectively when their brains demonstrate two properties: 1) a larger ERN signal, suggesting a bigger initial response to the mistake and 2) a more consistent Pe signal, which means that they are probably paying attention to the error, and thus trying to learn from it.
In this new paper, Moser et al. extends this research by looking at how beliefs about learning shape these mostly involuntary error-related signals in the brain, both of which appear in less than half a second. More specifically, the scientists applied a dichotomy first proposed by Carol Dweck, a psychologist at Stanford. In her influential research, Dweck distinguishes between people with a fixed mind-set — they tend to agree with statements such as “You have a certain amount of intelligence and cannot do much to change it” — and those with a growth mind-set, who believe that we can get better at almost anything, provided we invest the necessary time and energy. While people with a fixed mind-set see mistakes as a dismal failure — a sign that we aren’t talented enough for the task in question — those with a growth mind-set see mistakes as an essential precursor of knowledge, the engine of education.
The experiment began with a flanker task, a tedious assignment in which subjects are supposed to identify the middle letter of a five-letter series, such as “MMMMM” or “NNMNN.” Sometimes the middle letter is the same as the other four, and sometimes it’s different. This simple change induces frequent mistakes, as the boring task encourages people to zone out. Once they make a mistake, of course, they immediately regret it. There is no excuse for misidentifying a letter.
While performing the flanker task, subjects wore an EEG cap, a monitoring device filled with greased electrodes that records electrical activity in the brain. (Unlike fMRI, EEG gives researchers excellent temporal resolution, allowing them to precisely measure a sequence of neural events. Unfortunately, this comes at the expense of spatial resolution, making it difficult to know where in the brain the signals are coming from.)
It turned out that those subjects with a growth mind-set were significantly better at learning from their mistakes. As a result, they showed a spike in accuracy immediately following an error. Most interesting, though, was the EEG data, which demonstrated that those with a growth mind-set generated a much larger Pe signal, indicating increased attention to their mistakes. (While those with an extremely fixed mind-set generated a Pe amplitude around five, those with a growth mind-set were closer to fifteen.) What’s more, this increased Pe signal was nicely correlated with improvement after error, implying that the extra awareness was paying dividends in performance. Because the subjects were thinking about what they got wrong, they learned how to get it right.

Monday, December 3, 2012

Back Pain and MRIs


Back pain has reached epidemic proportions. The figures are sobering - there is a 70 percent chance that you will suffer from it at some point in your life and a 30 percent chance that you have had a back pain attack in the last 30 days. At any point of time about 1 percent of working age Americans are incapacitated by their lower lumbar regions and treatment is pretty much expensive accounting for $26 billion per year which is about 3 percent of the total health care spending. 
There has been a marked difference in the way we treat back pain with the discovery of MRI in the 1980s. Previous to that doctors had very little information or idea about the lower back region which is an exquisitely complicated body area full of tiny bones, ligaments, spinal discs and minor muscles. In the absence of information the only recourse that a doctor could take was to advice bed rest and surprisingly this proved to be a very effective remedy in that 90 percent of the patients got better within seven weeks. With the discovery of  MRI in the 1980s doctors have a stunningly accurate image of the lower back region but ironically that has made the problem worse. The machine simply gives too much of information and doctors as a result are unable to distinguish the significant from the irrelevant. The stunningly accurate images of the lower lumbar regions seen through an MRI are often misleading. The disc abnormalities which are apparent are seldom the cause of chronic back pain. In a 1994 an interesting study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, obtained images of the spinal regions of 98 people who had no history of back pain whatsoever. The images were then sent to doctors who didn't know that the patients weren't in pain. The result was shocking. The doctors reported that two-thirds of these normal patients exhibited "serious problems" such as bulging, protruding, or herniated discs. In 38 percent of these patients, the MRI revealed multiple damaged discs and nearly 90 percent of the patients exhibited some form of disc degeneration. These structural abnormalities are often used to justify surgery which sounds quixotic for people who have no history of back pain.
Similarly a large study published in the Journal of American Medical Association (JAMA) randomly assigned 380 patients with back pain to undergo two different types of diagnostic analysis. One group received x rays while the other group got diagnosed using MRIs which provided the doctors with much more detailed information about the underlying anatomy. Which group fared better? There was no difference in patient outcome. The vast majority of people in both groups got better - thus clearly more information didn't lead to less pain. But stark diff fences emerged when studies looked at how different groups were treated. Nearly 50 percent of the MRI patients were diagnosed with severe disc abnormalities requiring intensive medical interventions. These treatments were obviously more expensive and they had no measurable benefit.
Thus there is a danger of too much information and it can seriously interfere with our understanding. When the prefrontal cortex is overwhelmed, a person can no longer make sense of the situation. Correlation is confused with causation and people end up making theories out of coincidences. MRIs make it easier for doctors to see the lower lumbar region in vivid details highlighting all sorts of disc problems and so they reasonably conclude that these structural abnormalities are the cause behind back pain. They are usually wrong. Medical experts are now encouraging doctors not to order MRIs when evaluating back pain. A recent report in the New England Journal of Medicine, that MRIs should be used to image the back only under specific clinical circumstances - such as patients with a strong clinical suggestion of underlying infection, cancer or persistent neurologic deficit. In the latest clinical guidelines issued by the American College of Physicians and the American Pain Society, doctors were strongly recommended ... not to obtain imaging or other diagnostic tests in patients with non-specific low back pain. In too many cases expensive tests proved worse than useless and all the vivid imagery and detailing got in the way of effective diagnosis. Doctors thus performed better with less information.

 This interesting write up with some amount of editing on my part has been taken from the chapter titled "Choking on Thought" from,  How We Decide by Jonah Lehrer, Mariner Books, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, Boston, New York, 2010.